INDEPENDENCE LIBRARY CLOSED AFTER CAL OSHA SAFETY COMPLAINT
DECLARATION OF NO INDEPENDENCE
Inyo County has closed the Independence library branch to the public and library staff.
The library was closed in late August after the county received an anonymous complaint of serious health and safety violations in the space occupied by the library and its suite of offices along the hallway at the south half of the basement floor in the Inyo County courthouse in Independence.
The branch libraries in Bishop, Big Pine, Lone Pine, Tecopa and Shoshone remain open during their regularly scheduled days and times.
Longtime Library Director Nancy Masters is now working out of the Bishop branch library instead of Independence, which is the system’s central library.
The county did not notify the public of the closure except to place notices on both library doors that the library was being temporarily closed. The signs direct patrons to either the Lone Pine or Bishop libraries.
The closure and the uncertain current status of the library was brought up during the Sept. 29 Board of Supervisors meeting by several speakers during the board’s public comment agenda item. The board members did not respond to the questions or provide information on why the library was closed or when it might reopen.
Taped on one library door is a letter from the California Division of Safety and Health, dated Aug. 21, 2026. The letter states the department has received a complaint alleging five potential violations of state safety codes and regulations. The violations regard lack of training regarding handling hazardous chemicals; library shelving not anchored to the floor; numerous trip hazards created by extension cords placed across walkways; obstructed emergency exits; and fire extinguishers not readily available to staff.
The letter states the county has 14 days to investigate and mitigate any cited issues and report back to the state.
The complaint could open the county to liability that could result in “hundreds of thousands of dollars of fines” and other legal issues, said one confidential source familiar with the situation.
“This has been an issue for years and years,” said the source.
The county’s liability exposure could be substantial since county officials and several County Administrative Officers (CAO) have been made aware of at least three of the safety issues in the current complaint on numerous occasions, including through an extensive 2024 Grand Jury report.
The 2024 Grand Jury Report devoted nine pages of comments and photos to the section, “Safety Issues at the Independence Library.”
The potential safety issues with the new bookshelves in the main library not being anchored to the floor was fully documented in the report. It included manufacturer’s schematics and instructions and photos of the shelving.
The Grand Jury recommendation was for the county to, “Close the public area of the library and restrict employee access until the bookshelves are inspected and secured according to the manufacturer’s recommendations.”
The inspection of the staff working areas included the following finding: “Temporary lighting consisting of portable lights with extension cords, unsecured bookshelves, high storage on shelves and tripping hazards were observed.”
Inadequate and poorly placed fire extinguishers were also cited in the 2024 report.
Finding F3 states, “There is a well-documented history of persistent clutter, obstructed access and other safety related issues in the public and non-public areas in the Independence library.”
Some of the evidence cited for that conclusion includes: “Annual inspections by Inyo County Risk Management have consistently documented significant safety and access issues that vary in time as to severity and type. Obstruction of access, excessive clutter and storage in aisles and the center corridor being the most consistent over the period from 2019 to 2024.”
The report also states, “Numerous Inyo County employees noted longstanding, ongoing safety and access related issues in and adjacent to the library. There is no formal mechanism for a member of the public or county staff to present safety-related concerns.”
One of the final recommendations from the Grand Jury was, “Initiate a management and review process that will ensure safety issues are addressed promptly at the Independence Library and do not consistently reoccur by January 1, 2025.”
The recommendations were specifically forwarded to then-CAO Nate Greenberg and then-Public Works Director Mike Errante.
The filing of the CAL OSHA complaint came about two years after that Grand Jury report.
When contacted in the Bishop Library, Masters said she could not comment on the closure of the Independence central office.
Leslie Chapman, the Inyo County Assistant CAO from 2019 to 2021, then CAO in 2021 and 2022, asked the supervisors on Tuesday to address the library closure and plans to reopen the library in public at a future meeting. She said the library is a vital community service offering books, computer access, copies and vast historical records.
Becky Taylor, an Independence resident, said the library serves as a “community hub.” She echoed the value of the library to residents, especially those who cannot afford to drive to Lone Pine or Big Pine for similar library services. Closing the library has created “a major disruption in their lives.”
Mary Roper, Masters’ sister, noted the critical role played by the central library for cataloging book and providing internal services to the other branches. She asked the supervisors to “direct staff to open the library immediately.”
Lauren Rose, a Ph.D. candidate advocate for Friends of the Inyo, praised Masters and the library staff and said the facility was “an incredible resource for me,” and she had a “wonderful experience” doing research at the library.




